Skip to main content

Topped up Twice in a Year: Fix the Leak or Replace the Unit

A second top-up in a year is rarely bad luck. It almost always means an opening nobody found. The choice now is whether that leak is worth sealing on this unit.

On this page

Two top-ups in a year: repair or replace?

Find the leak first, then decide by where it is and how old the unit is. A joint, valve or exposed pipe is worth sealing at any age. A coil or concealed run on a unit past ten years usually is not.

Snowflake Aircon Services uses this rule once the leak is located. The repair and replacement quotes for the same rooms then settle it.

Scroll to see more columns

Two top-ups in a year: repair or replace? summary table
Where the leak isUnder 5 years5 to 10 yearsOver 10 years
Flare joint or service valveRepairRepairRepair
Exposed copper pipeRepairRepairRepair, unless other faults are present
Pipe in a wall or false ceilingRepair or re-routeCompare re-routing with replacementReplacement usually wins if the run must be renewed
Indoor or outdoor coilRepair; check the warranty firstCompare the coil quote with replacementReplacement usually wins
Not found yetSearch before decidingSearch before decidingSearch before deciding

Why a third top-up is the worst option

A sealed circuit does not use up refrigerant. Mitsubishi Heavy Industries' Singapore FAQ says a system that needs more gas is likely leaking.

The other cause is a unit undercharged at installation. Mitsubishi Electric's FAQ names both. A second refill within a year points to the leak.

Another refill pays for the same gas again. AIRAH's 2025 handling code forbids topping up a system before its leaks are fixed.

Bring the refill dates to the visit

The gap between refills is the most useful record you have. A shorter gap the second time means the opening is growing.

Write down each date and how long cooling held. The technician uses it to decide how hard and how wide to search.

What changes the answer on an older unit

Age alone does not condemn a unit. ENERGY STAR's advice for a system past ten years is a contractor's evaluation, not automatic replacement.

Three findings move an older unit toward replacement.

  • A coil leak: the repair replaces a major part on an ageing system.
  • Other faults in the same year: the leak is one sign of a wider decline.
  • A concealed run to renew: the repair already carries much of a new installation's work.

What to ask for at the next visit

Ask for a leak search, not a refill. Gas leak detection proves the leak with nitrogen, then places it, so the decision rests on a location.

If the leak is found, the gas leakage repair guide lists what the repair includes. If the unit shows other end-of-life signs, see the guide on signs your aircon needs replacing.

Common questions

Is it normal for an aircon to need gas top-ups every year?
No. An aircon's refrigerant circulates in a sealed circuit and is not used up in normal running. An aircon that needs gas every year is almost always leaking. The leak should be found with a pressure test and sealed before any more refrigerant is added to the system.
Is it worth fixing a gas leak on a 10-year-old aircon?
A gas leak at a joint or valve on a 10-year-old aircon is usually worth fixing, because the repair is small. A leak inside the coil or a concealed pipe run on a unit that age usually makes replacement the better spend, once both quotes cover the same rooms.
Why does my aircon keep losing gas after a top-up?
An aircon keeps losing gas after a top-up because the leak that emptied it was never sealed. The new refrigerant leaves through the same opening. If cooling fades faster the second time, the opening is probably growing, and a leak search should come before any more gas.
Should I top up my aircon gas a third time?
A third gas top-up pays for the same refrigerant again without closing the leak. Ask for a leak search instead. Once the leak's location is known, the choice between sealing it and replacing the aircon rests on evidence rather than on another refill.

Sources